This paper is quite theoretic and uses several important theorems of Mathematical Analysis. Well written and very readable.
page 4. Proof of proposition 1 and proposition 2 is not so straightforward as declared in the paper. So I just work it through step by step and here is the scanned version of my manuscript.
It's interesting to see in proposition 2 that the problem can be simplified into Bernoulii model.
Is there anyway that we can share our comments for papers?


Appendix I DUALITY. Lemma 4

4.b Auxiliary functions, Lemma3. One should notice the following theorem in Analysis:
For any compact set S and a sequence A in S, A must have a cluster point in S.
In proof of Proposition 5: because the sequence q^k belong to Q, so its cluster point must belong to the closure of Q.
Since Improved iterative Scaling algorithm is based on a bound function A(r,q), I strongly doubt that they could find an even better boundary function and further improve the convergence speed for the algorithm and I doubt that this problem could have already been solved somewhere in the optimization context.
No comments:
Post a Comment